Imagine a world where getting a home loan feels like navigating a maze rigged by the banks themselves—where only a select few players get to call the shots, leaving borrowers scrambling for fair deals. That's the alarming reality some experts are warning about in the mortgage industry today. But here's where it gets controversial: one bank is bucking the trend, and it's sparking heated debates about who really deserves the spotlight—brokers or the big lenders? Let's dive in and unpack this gripping story, making sure beginners can follow along every step of the way.
Published on November 10, 2025, this article highlights the clash between traditional banking giants and innovative players in Australia's mortgage market. At the center of the buzz is Macquarie Bank, which is flipping the script by channeling nearly 100% of its low-loan-to-value (LVR) mortgages through third-party brokers. For those new to the term, LVR simply refers to the percentage of the property's value that the loan covers—low LVR means borrowers are putting down a bigger deposit, often making loans less risky and more attractive. While competitors like ANZ are ramping up their in-house lending to squeeze more profit from tighter margins, Macquarie is doubling down on this broker-driven approach, setting itself apart in a crowded field.
As Wendy Brown, Macquarie's head of broker sales (featured in the image, center), passionately explained in a recent interview, the broker channel isn't just a sideshow—it's the engine powering their success. 'The broker channel has been and continues to be fundamental in enabling us to prudently grow our home loans business to where it is today, with brokers accounting for more than 95% of our home loan originations.' This strategy is paying off big time. Macquarie's loan portfolio ballooned by 13% year-over-year, outpacing the overall market's growth, and they've now captured about 6.5% of the national mortgage pie, climbing from 5.7% just six months prior.
FBAA's managing director, Peter White (shown on the right), isn't surprised by Macquarie's rise. In his view, brokers are the unsung heroes here, always prioritizing their clients' best interests. 'Brokers are bound to represent the best interests of their clients, and it's clear they're backing Macquarie because it’s delivering results,' White shared in a statement to our outlet. He points out that a whopping 95% of Macquarie's home loans now come through brokers, showing how savvy borrowers are becoming in a market brimming with fresh innovations. Unlike the big four banks, which often recycle the same tired products, Macquarie listens to what consumers actually want—think creative options that fit modern lives—and it's reaping the rewards.
'Brokers recognise a good deal when they see it and will only take the very best offers to their clients, whether it’s from Macquarie or any other lender,' White adds. And this is the part most people miss: in a hyper-competitive landscape, brokers act as savvy middlemen, scouting for top deals that banks might hide. For example, imagine a young couple shopping for their first home; a broker could uncover a Macquarie low-LVR loan with flexible terms that a traditional bank wouldn't advertise as prominently.
But here's the controversy that has everyone talking: White slams some major banks for pushing a 'closed shop' mentality, where they hog the market and cut back on broker support. 'The home loan market is more competitive than ever and increasingly driven by innovation, yet bizarrely some banks want it to be a closed shop, where they carve up the spoils,' he argues. This shortsightedness, he says, ignores how brokers actually boost these banks' loan volumes. 'It never ceases to amaze me that some banks view brokers as competitors, given the volume of loans brokers originate for them.'
The broker-bank tension has escalated lately, with Anja Pannek, CEO of the Mortgage and Financial Association of Australia (MFAA), chiming in through an open letter. She warns that Australia's banking sector is one of the most concentrated globally, and without brokers, borrowers would face fewer choices and steeper prices— a nightmare no one wants. 'Australia has one of the most consolidated banking systems in the developed world. Without brokers, Australian borrowers would be worse off, with fewer choices and more expensive mortgages. That’s an outcome no government, regulator or consumer advocate would welcome.'
Pannek flips the script, suggesting brokers aren't stealing business from banks—instead, banks are battling each other for market share. 'Brokers don’t compete with banks… banks compete with each other. Every pricing decision made by a lender positions them against other lenders and is driven by their own growth targets.' She calls out shady practices like secret in-branch pricing or rejecting broker-submitted applications only for them to get approved later, hinting at potential bias. Is this fair play, or a deliberate undercutting of brokers?
Yet, in the eye of the storm sits Commonwealth Bank, Australia's biggest mortgage lender, which insists brokers are essential. Their general manager for third-party banking, Baber Zaka (pictured left), told us: 'Mortgage brokers are at the heart of helping Australians into homes, and they remain central to our lending strategy. We're focused on growing our flows sustainably, by listening to our brokers and adapting our services to meet their needs.' To prove it, they've rolled out updates like revised debt policies for HELP loans, construction financing, and rental income options, giving brokers more wiggle room to help clients. They've also beefed up support with a new tiering system, more sales tools, and a national lead team, all aimed at smoother operations through better tech.
So, what's your take? Do you see brokers as the key to a fairer mortgage market, or are the big banks right to protect their turf? Share your thoughts in the comments—do you agree with Macquarie's approach, or should banks tighten control? Let's keep the conversation going!
Free e-newsletter
Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date with the world of mortgage. Please complete the form below and click on SIGN UP to receive daily e-newsletters from Mortgage Professional Australia.
Free e-newsletter
Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date with the world of mortgage.
